The Kentucky Retirement System breached its obligation to supply free retirement medical health insurance to state workers by canceling a number of retired cops’ medical health insurance as a result of that they had re-entered the workforce to take jobs with completely different state businesses. The officers’ eligibility for medical health insurance by way of their new employers was not a sound justification for the cancellation of their free retirement well being protection, and Medicare Secondary Payer laws didn’t require or enable this motion to be taken, in accordance with the sixth U.S. Circuit Courtroom of Appeals.
Kentucky ensures free medical health insurance to all public-sector workers who, upon retirement, meet sure age and years-of-service necessities. 5 cops who glad these necessities retired from the Louisville Metropolitan Police Division (LMPD) and commenced receiving the state-provided free retirement well being protection. When the officers turned 65, Medicare grew to become their major insurance coverage protection and Kentucky grew to become the secondary supplier, paying bills not lined by Medicare.
Finally, the cops got here out of retirement and re-entered the workforce, taking jobs with state businesses aside from the LMPD. The officers obtained salaries and medical health insurance from their new employers. When Kentucky realized that the officers had change into re-employed, it canceled their free retirement medical health insurance.
Kentucky knowledgeable the officers that it was required to cancel their free well being protection as a result of it was prohibited by Medicare from providing protection secondary to Medicare on condition that the officers had been “eligible to be on [their new] employer’s group well being plan” as “energetic workers.” The cops sued, claiming that Kentucky had breached its contract to supply them with free retirement medical health insurance. The trial court docket dominated in favor of the officers, and Kentucky appealed.
[Want to learn more? Join us at the SHRM Annual Conference & Expo 2021, taking place Sept. 9-12 in Las Vegas and virtually.]
The appeals court docket upheld the decrease court docket ruling.
Kentucky legislation requires the state to supply the officers with free well being protection following retirement and to not scale back these advantages at any time. Kentucky acknowledged that it had completed simply that, by canceling the officers’ protection, however incorrectly argued that “federal legislation made it do it,” in accordance with the appeals court docket.
Kentucky argued additional that the officers obtained their retirement medical health insurance by advantage of their present employment as a result of they labored for a similar employer that they had retired from. This was not correct, nonetheless, as a result of every of the officers labored for various county businesses than the LMPD. Whereas these businesses present medical health insurance to their workers by way of Kentucky, that didn’t make Kentucky their employer.
Kentucky violated its obligation below state legislation to not scale back or impair the officers’ retirement advantages, and Medicare laws didn’t present any justification for its actions, the court docket concluded.
River Metropolis Fraternal Order of Police Lodge 614 Inc. v. Kentucky Retirement Techniques, sixth Cir., Nos. 20-5773/5778 (June 8, 2021).
Skilled Pointer: This resolution ought to be of explicit curiosity to public-sector employers which can be required by state legislation to supply free retirement medical health insurance protection to retired workers. It’s pretty widespread for retirees to re-enter the workforce, and after they do, these employers mustn’t reflexively assume they’ll get rid of the numerous price of the free retirement medical health insurance by considering the retirees’ eligibility for well being protection by way of their new employer.
G. Bryan Adams III is an legal professional with Van Hoy, Reutlinger, Adams & Pierce PLLC, the Worklaw® Community member agency in Charlotte, N.C.